ICME Workflows:

Supplementing Finite Element Modelling with Calculated Thermophysical Properties

Temperature and chemistry-dependent thermophysical properties play an important role in finite element modeling (FEM) simulations. For example, thermal and fluid flow solvers, commonly used to model processes like casting, welding, and additive manufacturing processes, rely on temperature dependent properties, such as density, viscosity, surface tension, and thermal conductivity. Ma et al (2015) identified specific heat, thermal conductivity, and density as three of the top six critical variables for affecting peak temperature sensitivity when modeling a laser powder bed fusion process.

Handbooks are a common source of data, but these typically do not have temperature-dependent data for industrial alloys. Furthermore, data does not exist for novel materials, and handbooks do not capture the differences due to heat-to-heat variations in chemistry of a given alloy. It can be costly and time consuming to measure such data experimentally, but with Thermo-Calc you can calculate these properties as a function of material chemistry and temperature. These can then be used as inputs to FEM codes, resulting in more accurate predictions.

To assess the sensitivity to temperature-dependent values, Smith et al (2016) compared the effect of using handbook values for 316L for a constant specific heat and latent heat measured over a narrow solidus-liquidus temperature range with CALPHAD generated data and found that it had over a 500K difference in peak melt pool temperature and two times difference in the size of the melt pool.

Variation in composition, for example across a chemistry specification, can also be captured and understood, as discussed in our blog post How to Use Sensitivity Calculations to Evaluate the Effect of Composition Variation on Critical Phase Transformation Temperatures.

In Figure 1 below, the room temperature thermal conductivity has been calculated across the Alloy 718 chemistry range and is shown as a histogram. Note the roughly 10% variation in thermal conductivity. These calculations are all for valid chemistries that fall into the alloy 718 specification range. Engineers can use this to specify tighter or custom chemistry specification ranges, or to simply calculate new properties and re-validate FEM models when new heats of material are acquired.


Figure 1: Room temperature thermal conductivity calculated across the Alloy 718 chemistry range and shown as a histogram.

CALPHAD and FEM in an ICME Framework

CALPHAD tools and FEM can be linked more closely in ICME frameworks, as demonstrated by Dr. Adam Hope of Thermo-Calc and Fernando Okigami of Hexagon. Presented at the Advances in Welding and Additive Manufacturing Research 2022 conference, the authors detail how calculated CALPHAD based material properties can be used as inputs to the FEM code Simufact Additive to make a thermal model for a given set of build parameters. Figures 2 and 3 show the calculated thermal conductivity and heat capacity as a function of temperature for a specific chemistry. Alloy 718 was used because there exists high quality measured thermophysical data to compare to. Good agreement was found between the FEM models when using calculated vs experimental data.


Figure 2: Calculated thermal conductivity as a function of temperature for Alloy 718. Good agreement is shown between the FEM models when using calculated vs experimental data.


Figure 3: Calculated heat capacity as a function of temperature for Alloy 718. Good agreement is shown between the FEM models when using calculated vs experimental data.

Calculating Thermophysical Properties in Thermo-Calc

Performing calculations to generate thermophysical property data is easy using Thermo-Calc. You can watch a video tutorial here for an example for electrical resistivity and thermal conductivity for pure copper:

Learn More about Calculating Thermophysical Properties with Thermo-Calc

Whether you’re an experienced user or simply curious about Thermo-Calc, we’d be happy to show you over a web call how to set up a cross plot that could help you in your work. Schedule a free consultation today!

Learn more about Fitting into ICME frameworks

By providing composition and temperature dependent data that link models across different length scales, Thermo-Calc’s software and databases are an integral tool in ICME frameworks. Many properties can be calculated under different conditions that reflect differences in processing. For example, properties that may vary with cooling rates or through non-isothermal heat treatments, and more.

Let Us Help You

Is Thermo-Calc Right for You?

Talk to one of our experts to learn whether our tools fit your needs.