Hoppa till innehål
lightweighting-rocket-components-header_v02



CASE STUDY: Multi-Material Additive Manufacturing | Thermo-Calc Solutions

Enabling Lighter Multi-Material Rocket Components

See how Thermo-Calc Solutions’ predictive materials design helped Skyrora develop a nickel-titanium rocket propulsion component approximately 44% lighter than the original nickel-alloy design, with no damage detected after six live firings in a 3.5 kN engine.

44%
lighter

component mass than the original design

Produced
crack-free

via directed energy deposition AM

No damage
detected

after multiple hot-fire tests

NiTi_Objective_1500x1000_AI_Generated

The Objective

Combining Nickel and Titanium for Lighter Rocket Components

Multi-material additive manufacturing enables different alloys to be integrated within a single component, placing each material where its properties deliver the greatest performance benefit. For rocket propulsion components, this means having nickel alloys where high-temperature strength and thermal stability are essential while introducing titanium to help with lightweighting.

Through the MADE-3D project, Skyrora partnered with Thermo-Calc Solutions to develop a suitable transition between these traditionally incompatible alloy systems, enabling a single component that leverages the strengths of both materials.

The Challenge

Nickel-Titanium Joining Can Cause Cracking

While the performance benefits of combining nickel and titanium alloys are clear, directly joining these two alloys presents several challenges:

  • Brittle intermetallic phases:
    Mixing nickel and titanium alloys produces detrimental phases that increase susceptibility to cracking.
  • Suitable intermediate materials:
    Intermediate materials and layers must provide a compatible joining pathway between the two alloys.
  • Structural reliability:
    The proposed joining method must be manufacturable and maintain its integrity in real-world conditions.

Overcoming these challenges requires carefully designed intermediate layers that control local composition as well as phase formation. And here, identifying suitable transition pathways through experimental trial and error alone is both time-consuming and costly.

NiTi_Challenge_1500x1000_AI_Generated

The Approach

Designing a Graded Ni-Ti Transition with ICME

Thermo-Calc Solutions applied an ICME approach to identify the mechanisms responsible for cracking and guide the design of the intermediate layer between the nickel and titanium alloys. Computational predictions as well as experimental feedback guided the selection and refinement of intermediate compositions, focusing development on the most promising solutions.

 

A graphic that lists the four steps used in the ICME workflow: input, predict, evaluate, and output.

Map showing predicted crack susceptibility (heat map) versus experimental observations (stars) as a function of composition mixtures between Ni and Ti alloys. The green lines exemplify a composition path to avoid the issue.
Map showing predicted crack susceptibility (heat map) versus experimental observations (stars) as a function of composition mixtures between Ni and Ti alloys. The green lines exemplify a composition path to avoid the issue.

The Solution

Mapping a Path to Crack-Free Joining

Thermodynamic simulations were used to identify a compositional pathway that avoided detrimental phase formation (see image), guiding the design of intermediate layers. Experimental observations were then used to assess the proposed transition and refine the pathway toward crack-free joining.

Skyrora Ltd. implemented this solution in a DED-manufactured rocket propulsion component, supported by manufacturing and validation work across the MADE-3D consortium (Skyrora, Exponential Technologies, f3nice, Universität Paderborn, CSEM, and the University of the Aegean).

A graphic that says Validated Composition Benefits: 44% lighter than the original nickel-alloy and Crack-free after six successful live-firings.

The Benefits

Faster Development, Lower Risk, Lighter Components

Predictive materials design enabled targeted experiments, saving time and guiding the development of a lighter propulsion component successfully demonstrated through hot-fire testing.

Benefits include:

  • Faster development: Focused materials investigations and validation on promising transition compositions.
  • Lower technical risk: Addressed the metallurgical causes of cracking before progressing to component manufacture.
  • Cost savings: Drastically fewer experiments.
  • Improved Component Performance: ~44% weight reduction while maintaining performance.
Video-thumbnail-fire-testing-mult-material-rocket-component

Development and Validation

 Six Live Firings with No Detected Component Damage

Predictive modelling and targeted experiments supported the development of the solution in less than three and a half years, with reduced testing, cost, and technical risk compared with a conventional trial-and-error approach.

The multi-material component was subsequently demonstrated through six live firings of the developed LEO 3.5 kN engine of Skyrora. Inspections before and after the campaign found no damage to the modified component. These results connect the materials design work to a demonstrated engineering outcome: a lighter propulsion component with a graded transition that withstood hot-fire testing.

NiTi_Engineers_AM_Component_1500x1000_AI_Generated

Broad Applicability

Applying ICME to Other Multi-Material AM Challenges

This approach illustrates how ICME can support the development of graded material transitions for demanding additive manufacturing applications. Thermo-Calc helps teams identify promising material combinations and focus testing, enabling faster development with lower technical risk.

Key audiences:

  • Materials R&D teams
  • Additive manufacturing engineers
  • Aerospace and propulsion manufacturers
  • AM service providers
  • OEMs developing multi-material components
case-study-PDFs-lightweighting-rocket-components

Download the Case Study

Download this case study as a PDF to save for future reference or share with your colleagues.

Start a Conversation

Bring Us Your Materials Challenge

Contact us and tell us about your materials challenges. Our experts will help you assess whether an ICME approach fits your development needs.

Let Us Help You

Is Thermo-Calc Right for You?

Talk to one of our experts to learn whether our tools or services fit your needs.